A plea to fellow researchers Break free of walled gardens and build your own digital gardens

[[ daily blog post ]]: https://www.buriedsecretspodcast.com/a-plea-to-fellow-paranormal-researchers-break-free-of-walled-gardens-and-build-your-own-digital-gardens/

A plea to fellow paranormal researchers: break free of walled gardens and build your own digital gardens

Earlier this year, one of my favorite thinkers, sci-fi author Cory Doctorow coined the term “enshittification.”

Enshittification is the process of a platform destroying itself. It often goes like this: the platform initially seems great, so users sign up, then it shafts its users in favor of attracting business users, then it screws businesses over to draw in advertisers, and then the whole thing devolves into an unusable pile of mush.

The term has caught on because it’s so perfect for our time. (You can read about it on Doctorow’s blog or hear about it on his podcast form.)

Many of the largest platforms are currently in particularly mushy stages. (Twitter comes to mind most readily, but it certainly isn’t the only one. Pretty much everyone knows that Instagram, Facebook, and Amazon are garbage as well.)

One of many problems with enshittification is that when a social media platform implodes, users lose a lot, from the social connections that they made on the platform to the content that they created. (Ditto with if, say, a platform suddenly decides to ban or delete your account, something that seems to happen to users with alarming frequency.)

If you create your content inside a walled garden, you don’t control it. Social media algorithms allow people to potentially get more exposure. But for the most part, you’re stuck making content for free for a platform that can just delete it all or block people from seeing it at a whim.

Doctorow compares the success of some lucky folks on social media to the phenomenon of someone walking around a county fair with a giant teddy bear. All of the games in the midway are rigged, so no one’s winning the grand prize unless someone lets them. But the thing is, if you let one person get the prize, a big ol’ teddy bear, they’ll walk around all day with that bear, advertising the games. People will see that and believe that the games are winnable. After all, that person won the teddy bear, so why not me?

The teddy bear, like success on social media, is just part of the trap.

By the time a platform is enshittified, the teddy bears have already been handed out. Any surplus or reward that was gonna be given to users has been sucked away. The platform essentially becomes an attention mine for ad bucks.

The implications of a few giant corporations controlling so much of the content that we create—so much of the fabric of our lives—are chilling.

In a recent issue of the Garbage Day newsletter, Ryan Broderick writes about a deceased friend’s tweets, which, according to statements from Twitter about inactive accounts, might soon be deleted. He descripts his sadness about potentially losing that last connection to a lost friend.

He writes:

I’ll be realistic here. I don’t think we should expect every company to keep our content forever, but I also don’t think they should get to unilaterally shrink the internet because they’re tired of being responsible for its upkeep. The internet shouldn’t be a handful of company towns that can pull up their stakes and leave when the data mine is tapped.

Broderick also talks about how someone discovered that Twitter was un-deleting people’s deleted posts.

So, within the walled gardens of social media, you have neither a right to be remembered nor a right to be forgotten.

It’s hard to say what rights we have at all.[^1] That’s unacceptable, even if you’re just online to follow friends and family.

But it becomes a whole nother thing when you’re on social media sharing your creative and intellectual work.

I’d like to address this post to fellow paranormal researchers, but really I’m talking to everyone who creates content and posts it only to social media.

We’ve been taught that our work is and should be ephemeral, grist for the content mill that keeps social media worth going back to. Posting to social media has its purpose: communication. However, it’s also sucked in content that once would have been archived on personal blogs—much of that content is extremely valuable and deserves to be shared more widely.

But instead it’s trapped inside the walled gardens of social media, subject to the whim of big tech companies and potentially hidden from people to free up more space for advertisements on your followers’ feeds.

Why more paranormal researchers should tend their own digital gardens

This week, I’ve been writing about digital gardens, which are of course distinct from the walled gardens of social media (despite the similar terminology).

A digital garden is a low-lift, casual collection of personal notes that are published online. It’s a constant work in progress, a place to link your thinking, develop your thoughts, and learn in public.

Yesterday, I wrote about how you can easily set one up for yourself online.

I’ve enjoyed poking around in existing digital gardens, but many of them focus heavily on tech and personal knowledge management. Those are just two of many subjects that I’m interested in, and I’d be thrilled if more paranormal folks set up digital gardens for their own research.

Right now, I learn about what people are researching primarily through random social media posts.

Which is fine, sort of.

I think I’ve already established some of the issues with social media. But in addition to those, research posted to social media becomes 1) hard to search for and almost impossible to track back down (especially when they live in self-destructing posts like Instagram stories), 2) difficult to cite, 3) hidden inside walled gardens, which makes it inaccessible to anyone who doesn’t use the platforms you do. (I’m talking about corporate social media and setting aside interoperable social media like the fediverse here, to be clear.)

Disappearing posts

On social media, if someone takes down a post, it’s gone.

When I do research for my podcast and blog, I often stumble upon old blog posts that contain links to other, dead blogs. But I can easily plug that dead link into the Wayback Machine and access the page there.

But what do you do if a social media post is taken down? I don’t think social media is archived the same way that blog posts are. (Not as far as I could discern.)

On top of that, you can’t just search the Wayback Machine using keywords. You need a specific URL to plug in.

In a world with fewer blogs (since they’ve mostly been replaced by social media), there are fewer places to find outgoing links to interesting content. Which means that there are fewer breadcrumb-like dead links that can lead to amazing archived defunct sites.

So that means that when a social media post goes down, it’s probably gone for good. (Unless that person was a public figure and people were screen grabbing everything they posted, something that probably won’t be the case for folks doing paranormal research.)

Citation difficulties

I often see interesting paranormal tidbits on social media while I’m in a half-glazed doomscroll trance. Then can’t remember where I saw it, who did which experiment, or the content of exactly what they did.

Or even worse, sometimes I think of something and can’t remember if it’s one of my own original ideas or something that I saw half paying attention while scrolling on social media. And then searching doesn’t surface it, because of the severe limitations when it comes to searching social media.

But you know what is easier to search, and what gets archived? A blog. And if you have a set of bookmarks or an RSS feed, it becomes easier to check the places that you know you read and search them.

I’m now at the point where I find myself taking notes on social media posts so I can (hopefully) properly cite other people’s research. Which, again, is fine, but it’s not a long-term solution for archiving the brilliant thoughts of other researchers. It’s just a way for me to have a skimpy record of the tidbits that interested me.

Paranormal research has value

I would really like to see more people treating their research and experiences with the respect they deserve, archiving them in blogs or even on something lower effort like a digital garden.

I don’t fault anyone for keeping their work within the walled gardens of social media.

It’s free and easy. We’re encouraged to do so.

In fact, we’re actively discouraged and punished for sharing external links on platforms like Instagram. So if you set up shop outside of a walled garden, good luck getting people to actually see it.

Social media crushes creativity

I started promoting my blog on Instagram, posting stories that contained links to posts. Based on my back-of-the-envelope math, my Instagram story views went down by 30-70%.

As an experiments I stopped posting links and promoting my writing, and my story views went back up to more “normal” levels.

Though even before than, an extremely small percentage of my 1,200 or so followers even saw my stories and posts.

In fact, that’s why I stopped posting Instagram Reels. I know they’d help with growth. But I got too pissed off at being forced to do all this extra work creating content for a platform (for, again, no compensation and no promise that it’d actually net me more followers, or that any new followers would actually see my stuff).

It’s frustrating. So many of us are on social media to share the cool stuff we’re creating elsewhere. But then it disincentivizes the actual creative work and only (sometimes) rewards us for creating whatever content fits best into their ever-changing roadmap of which features they’re pushing.

Setting up your digital garden, blog, or website

Again, I talked about how I set up my digital garden yesterday. You can set up a website really easily, and for free.

The method I used—Github for hosting, Netlify, as a CDN, and a premade Jekyll template—is an easy and free (or very low cost) way to have a place for your notes online. And you really don’t need to have any tech savvy to do it.

You could also set up a website on Neocities, a charming callback to Geocities that allows people to create free (or cheap, if you want to bring your own domain name) static sites.

There are other free and cheap options, like using Hugo and Github or setting up a Write Freely instance.

If you write about weird stuff, you can reach out to the lovely people at Liminal Earth, who already operate a Write Freely instance for people who want to blog about weird things.

And I haven’t even talked about ways of building website like Wordpress (which I used to use), Ghost (which I currently use), and the many others that exist out there.

All of this to say: there are many, many different ways to create a home for your paranormal research online that isn’t hidden within a social media walled garden.

And if blogging is too heavy of a lift, there are more casual options like digital gardening, where you can share less formed, more fluid thoughts.

If you’re eager to learn more about building a non-social media home for yoruself online and things like POSSE (publish on your own site, syndicate everywhere, which is what I do for this blog), check out IndieWeb for additional ideas and information.

Also, if you do set up your own blog, remember to include an RSS feed link alongside all of your social links, so that way your readers can choose to get all of your posts via their RSS readers, versus whatever the spotty social media algorithms decide to show them.

Since the surge in social media walled gardens’ popularity and the demise of Google Reader a decade ago, RSS feeds have become less popular. But they’re still an amazing way to follow your favorite creators, and I think they’re poised for a comeback.

I want to see your digital garden

Anyway, that’s my impassioned plea for fellow paranormal researchers to share and archive their work on platforms that they own and that anyone can access. Though I’m sure this won’t be the last time that I grouse about this topic.

If you set up a digital garden because of any of my posts about it, please let me know! I’d love to see other folks’ digital gardens. Especially digital gardens created by other paranormal researchers. Ditto if you set up a blog. Send me that RSS feed and I’ll add it to my RSS reader!

[^1] I know the GDPR is a thing, but I live in the states, and I hear that the ways in which things have been made GDPR compliant have been . . . a whole non-ideal process that I’m not going to get into here.

digital gardens [[ digital enclosure ]] [[ blogging ]]

Backlinks

There are no notes linking to this note.


Here are all the notes in this garden, along with their links, visualized as a graph.

1897 north texas airships episode appendix...1897 ufo flap in north texas1897 airship flap1897 airship reports per jacques vallee1897 airship sightings and the aurora, texas,...Embarking on a quest2023 03 14 when ghosts feel more real than the...2023 03 15 ghost hunting as nostalgia2023 03 27 diy rem pod initial build blog post and...2023 04 03 learning things2023 04 10 learning things2023 04 20 link roundup2023 04 24 learning things blog post2023 05 01 learning things2023 05 08 learning things2023 05 09 link roundup2023 05 22 learning things2023 05 29 learning things2023 07 03 learning things2023 07 10 learning things2023 07 17 learning things Link roundupA trojan feast The food and drink offerings of...Accidentally overriding reality Untrustworthy and...All my homies hate skrillex video essay about the...Allan kardec's orders of spiritsAs we may think by vannevar bushBelbury poly bandBritish folk horrorChapter 21 stone tapes Ghost box, nostalgia, and...Closed deckCory doctorowCreativityCurse of the luxor hotel blog post part 1Curse of the luxor hotel blog post part 4Curse of the luxor hotel blog post part 5Curse of the luxor hotel blog post part 6Curse of the luxor hotel blog post part 7Curse of the luxor hotel blog post part 8Curse of the luxor hotel blog post part 9EmfEspEsszettel and devotional pictures for swallowingEstes methodFire might give paranormal entities power,...Forteans are garbage collectors sifting through...From human to alienGateway tapes and experienceGentry faeGeorgiana houghton's artGeorgiana houghton's seance processGeorgiana houghtonGhost box record labelGhost box records uses radical nostalgia to...Ghost hoaxing blog postsGilitruttGrylaHallucinatory men in black anomaly newsletter...Hallucinatory ufos and sound anomaly newsletter...Hellebore magazineHemi SyncHilma af klint began having visions as a childHilma af klint by julia vossHilma af klint considered st. george her alter egoHilma af klint may have been influenced by a...Hilma af klint was an aristocratHilma af klint was queerHilma af klintHow i use randonautica in 2023. the pointlessness...Iceland has a good stepmother trope in folkloreIcelandIcelandic folk legends by alda sigmundsdottirIcelandic folkloreIcelandic ghosts tend to be maliciousIcelandic trolls and ogresIt seems to me that the past is always happening...Jacques valleeJohannes kelpius and philadelphia's occult monks...John keel and nostalgiaJohn keel says wednesdays are the best day to spot...John keel's anomaly newsletterJohn lennon experienced an apport in 1974Joshua cutchinLearning to use extrasensory perception by charles...Liminal earthLiminal spaceLimitless mind by russell targMichael pursinger came up with the idea of emfs...Michael pursinger wrote about humans and the...Michael pursingerMore magical times and places to see a ufo or do...My gateway tapes experiment so farNad, or paranormal music experiencesNever travel in an airship without a cat The...New blood kickstarter blog postNotes for a diy rem pod buildOn mylar balloons and forgotten futures blog postOperation trojan horse by john keelPanasonic rr Dr60Paranormal investigation techniquesParanormal investigationParanormalPassport to magonia by jacques valleePerceptions and bias, bibliomancy Inspired writingPicatrixPrinceton engineering anomalies research, or pearRandonautica book info on voids and anomaliesRandonauticaRaymond moodyReadingRussell targSpirit boxes and radios Analog ghost huntingSpirit highways and city infrastructureStone tape theoryThe brimstone deceit by joshua cutchinThe invisible night schoolThe memex methodThe owl's map by belbury polyThe philosopher's stone in philadelphiaThe pigman of bonnie brae bridgeThe seance at hobs lane by mount vernon arts labThe more attention you place on hiding something,...The television picture is a man Made ghost. T. c....Thieves in the night a brief history of...Third eye spies Learn remote viewing from the...Thomas edison on the ufo flap of 1897TopicTrusting your own perceptionUaps, uavs, and other new ufo euphemisms blur...Ufo occupants might create a diversion to distract...UfoUfos are environmental phenomenon rather than etsUfos pay attention to state linesUpton sinclair wrote a book about psychic powersUpton sinclairVan cortlandt park ufo sighting, bronx, nyVintage ufo detectorsWufoWednesday phenomenonWhy is it easier to capture paranormal evidence...Window areas and how to find magnetic faults near...A few large companies shouldn't be allowed to...A plea to fellow researchers Break free of walled...A proposed esp testing aidA reading list of 150 ufo Related booksA relaxation device claims to use emf to calm you...A type One error or rejection of true hypothesis,...A youtuber made a vr game like beatsaber with...Affordable ghost huntingAi is the anti Printing pressAiAlchemyAlien abductees given eggsAlien or fae abductionAlien with frog Like eyes from an egg shaped craftAliens in ufos are the same as the faeAnalog tools for paranormal investigation episode...Analysis is bad for psychic workAnalytical overlay, aol, or mental noiseArt and the creative process is like dowsingArtArtistAuthorAutomatic writing planchette blog post, essay...Bad architecture and hauntings, extrapolated to my...Batteries and the paranormalBatteries don't drain because spirits want their...Best time for psychic workBinaural beatsBlog post The nauga, an urban legend created by...Blogs broke the webBreaking through to the faerie realmBuckwheat and the faeBuilding a digital garden in jekyllChangelingChant codes websiteComing down with a fever after an alien or ufo...Confidence calls are weighted more heavily in...Cozy webDefinition of digital gardenDenial and doubtDigital garden blog post How toDigital garden terms of serviceDigital gardening and zettlekasten blog postDigital gardens can be more personal, like a...Digital gardensDigital stream, campfires and gardensDream before seeing ufoDreamsDrop of water appearing out of nowhereDuring geomagnetic storms, your dreams are fucked...Egg loreEgg shaped ufo sighting in 1965Egg Related antidote to the evil eye, in the...Electromagnetic interference degrades psychic...ElectromagneticElectronic musicElves and hidden people in icelandEmf meterEpisode about instant photography, nostalgia, and...Episode about nostalgia, the paranormal, and...Ergodic literatureExtroverts do better in esp workFae asks for oatmealFae folkloreFae foodFaeFairy taleFeelings of nostalgia insulate us from our fear of...Ferrite beads help block em interferenceFertilizer gift for aliensFictional town of belburyFolkloreFollowing a vintage automatic writing planchette...Food stolen by aliensGetting to fairylandGhostGreek mythologyHauntology is a music genreHearing musical samples from the 70s that are...Hellgate as a paranormal emotive touchpointHistoryHoaxHoaxes and trickstersHow things fail matter more than how they workHow to set up an obsidian digital garden for freeIn 1897, the technology wasn't there to make quick...In parapsychology studies, closed decks skew...Instant photography Analog ghost huntingIt's rare for radioactivity to show up in ufo...Learning is reinforced, and the shorter the...LearningLiminalLiminalityMagical plantsMagnetic metal found at ufo landing siteMany people fear success more than failureMarbendill, half dwarf, half fishMargígur, half human, half fishMaybe the fae and aliens don't eat saltModern automatic writing planchettes blog postModern science rules over a narrow universe, re...Mortality salience hypothesis blog postMortality salience hypothesisMusicMy digital garden blog post My goalsNegative factors in ufo casesNew modular devices blog postNostalgia and the fear of death blog postNostalgia can twist into disorientationNostalgiaNotetakingNykur, or water horseOccultOgreOicotypeOily ufo circlePalimpsestPancake from a flying saucerParanormal artParanormal emotive touchpointParanormal gearParanormal investigation gadgets are a buffer...Paranormal phenomena and forteana occurs on a 9.6...Paranormal soundParanormal theoriesParapsychologyPlaces to encounter the fae after 1850Plants can tell when you're touching themPlants scream when stressedPlantsPoltergeistProtectionPsiPsychicPsychogeographyPsychokinesisPsychomanteumQuoteRecurrent spontaneous psychokinesis or rspk, aka...Remote viewingRetrocausalitySampling as virtual collaborationShopping cart locks use emfSilly old scientific explanations for faerie ringsSimilarities betwen ufo encounters and folkloreSince she came from a family with nautical roots,...Skoffín, female cat male fox offspringSolarpunkSolfeggio frequenciesSome icelandic folktales may have been the result...Some ufo contact cases are induced hallucinationsSome contactees hear things in their mind rather...Some men in black may be hallucinatorySome people have prophetic dreams after ufo...Some scientific reports are biased in favor of the...Stages of remote viewingSteampunkTechTerror management theory (tmt)Terror management theory blog postThe oz factorThe ufonauts are liars and hoaxers, not the...The best time, month, and place to see a ufoThe cozy web, as opposed to the dark forestThe digital garden vs. the digital streamThe digital is impermanentThe generation effectThe hitchiker effect through social contagionThe hitchiker effect, when paranormal things...The internet is for ghostsThe most magical days, when you can spot witches...There's a difference between a digital garden and...Thinking through writingTimeTo be right, you have to be willing to be wrongTraits of precognitive dreamsTricksters live in liminal spaces, and after the...TrollUfo faerie rings Vallee's summaryUfo foodUfo nests in australia 1966Ufos, the fae, and imaginationUnheimlichUnspace, the raw shark texts, and ergodic...Urban legendVideo about full spectrum photography and visible...We must not heap theory on theory, dream upon...When we read something, we think we understand it,...Window areas and magnetic deviationWindow areasWorldview defensesYou need people who can talk you out of your bs...Zettlekasten